Home › New York › Shelter Island
Running trails in Shelter Island, NY
Shelter Island has 1 trail in the directory. Every one posts opening hours, so you can check the gate before an early start. They're ranked here by rating weighted by review volume, across 310 Google reviews. Filter by surface, loop, distance, shade or lighting to get to the run you're actually planning — no made-up difficulty score, just the facts you'd check before driving out.
Mashomack Preserve
4.8 ★★★★★ 310 reviews
MixedScenic
A 2,039-acre coastal nature reserve on an island established in 1980 with marshes, forest & creeks.
No trails match those filters.
How to pick a trail in Shelter Island
- Match the surface to your legs. Most of what's here is mixed (1 of 1). Asphalt and concrete are fast, predictable and runnable year-round but the least forgiving; crushed limestone and dirt take the sting out of high mileage; boardwalk is flat and scenic but slick in the wet. If your shins or knees are complaining, the fix that actually works is varying the surface you run on rather than chasing one "best" one. More mixed trails →
- Loop or out-and-back? A loop finishes back at the car with no backtracking; on an out-and-back you simply turn round at half your distance.
- Check the hours before a 6am run. Plenty of trails sit inside parks that gate at dusk and don't unlock until well after sunrise, so a trail that's perfect at lunchtime can be locked at 6am. 1 of the 1 listing carries posted opening hours — worth a look before you set an alarm.
- Long run? Check water and restrooms first. 1 has trailhead parking and 1 has restrooms in Shelter Island. Anything over an hour and those stop being nice-to-haves — and in summer, shade counts double.
- The small things that decide it. 1 with mile markers, 1 that runners describe as quiet, and 1 smooth and wide enough for a stroller or a wheelchair. Busy or quiet isn't a good-or-bad thing here: a busy path is the safer choice for a solo run at dawn, a quiet one is better for intervals.
More on all of this in the trail-running guides.
Browse Shelter Island trails by type
Running trails near Shelter Island
Worth the short drive — the closest towns with trails in the directory.